Here’s my take on this season’s HOF nominees. We finally inducted a few last year, but there are still plenty of eligible candidates! Look at my “borderline” list, and you’ll see a bunch of guys that would be no-doubt HOFers in the real world. Gives some perspective on how hard it is to pitch in this league.
Darren Owens – The career HR leader at 788. .310/.409/.631/1.040. 2000+ RBIs. 5-time MVP!!!!!! No doubt whatsoever.
Pablo Vincente – Finally a 1B who stands out of the crowd! He hit .305/.393/.603 (.996) with 667 HR. 5th all-time with 1927 RBI (for perspective, here is the list: Owens, Harper, Lombardi, Glynn, Vincente). Won an MVP, went to 6 all-star games, and won 2 silver sluggers. Combines the great peak with excellent longevity, and gets my nod.
Jorel McGlinchy – A tough call, not an amazing offensive player, though respectable with over 500 2Bs, 200 SBs and an .812 career OPS. But an absolutely incredible defensive force, winning 10 GGs at CF and going to 8 All Star games. Racked up 424 (+) plays – the second most is 146. If you value defense, this guys is a HOFer.
Kelly Grace – The best pitcher on this list finishes at 213-143, for a spectacular .598 winning percentage. He won a CYA, went to 6 AS games, and finished with a 1.22 WHIP and a 3.52 ERA. Now look around this list and see how many people hit over 500 HR and OPS over .900. Try not to judge pitchers relative to real baseball! This guy most likely a HOFer.
Al Maurer – Career RF who slugged 485 HR while putting up .324/.407/.574 (.981 OPS). Amazingly consistent, he went to 10 All Star Games, won 3 SS and 2 GG.
Stan Lee – Yet another player whose numbers would be good enough in another system, but will probably not see the HOF in HBD. 462 HR with over 1600 R & RBI, plus 380 SB. A .953 career OPS. 4 AS teams, 5 Silver Sluggers and 2 MVPs! But I doubt he’ll get enough support.
Clinton Anderson – This RF hit an enormous 667 HR, drove in over 1800, and scored over 1600. His .921 OPS is very good but does not elevate him from this group. He won an MVP, but only went to 2 All Star games.
David Wanatabe – The all-time Saves leader by a mile, with 623. Went to 10 All Star games and won 5 Fireman awards. But he only pitched 50 IP more than Nerio, with a 3.67 ERA. Hard to say who was better. Some will vote for him. I probably won’t.
Denny Cooper – Second all-time in SBs with 721, this speedster also got on base and hit for power, giving him an .897 career OPS. 4 All Star games and 4 Silver Sluggers. He also played an excellent 2B. Another high-level candidate.
Evan Moore – Gets the accumulater vote, but was never as good as the rest of the guys in this category. A solid .869 OPS with over 500 2Bs is very nice, but the only reason he’s this high is because of the 3000 H. Only one All Star game. I personally wouldn’t put him in until a lot of these other guys get in. Played 1B for his whole career despite being listed as a 2B on his HOF card.
Roosevelt Davenport – A victim of too many good players – he’s next in line to a lot of guys. Should get lots of respect for 586 HRs and a .920 OPS, but only went to 3 All Star games. He played a below average 2B for most of his career, then played an above average LF.
Darin McClellan – A Davenport clone, he hit 589 HRs and had a .921 OPS. Despite that he only went to 1 All Star game. Played 1B, LF and DH. Doesn’t really stand out.
Sid Watson – The next in line to Wanatabe. Fewer saves (479), one fewer ASG (9), 100 fewer IPs (850) and a similar ERA (3.61). A reasonable person would have to vote for Wanatabe first.
Claude Long – More excellent numbers that don’t quite make it. 562 HR with a .922 OPS. Played most of his career at LF. 5 ASGs and 6 Silver Sluggers.
Jim Heathcott – Played 2B/3B, and batted .300. Comes in with a mediocre .813 OPS. His claim to HOF is his 3153 H, and would probably deserve some consideration if we had 10 votes each. But despite his high level consistency I just don’t think he was as good as the players above him. I know some will disagree, but how many HOFers only play in 1 all-star game?
Chuck Coleman – Mostly played SS, and hit for good power with 413 HR. His .899 OPS is very nice, he went to 4 AS games, won a Silver Slugger at SS and a GG at RF. I think he may be just below HOF level.
Ringo Weston – Played CF, SS and 3B, got over 2300 H and 1300 R, with an OPS of .845. Excellent all-around player, maybe not quite HOF quality.
Al Cedeno – A very similar player to Weston, played SS, 3B and RF, almost 2300 H and 1200 R, .840 OPS. Just one AS game, and a GG in RF, and he’s clearly not quite a HOFer.
Geronimo Ordaz – Almost made it to 3000 H as a SS and compiled an .850 OPS. He compares in some ways to Desi Rodriguez, but never won a gold glove and only went to 3 All-Star games. One step below.
Alberto Sosa – Hard to argue against players with 550 HR, but this RF is going to come up a hair short with his .890 OPS, and the fact he only played in 2 All Star games.
Dean Brennaman – Won an MVP, went to 3 all-star games, and put up an amazing 1.045 OPS. But he only played 5 full seasons. Was old when the league started.
T.J. Smart – Another early C with huge seasons, but a too short career. Has a massive .998 OPS, but fewer than 1000 H and only 175 HR.
Albert Tatis – A brilliant defender, Tatis won 5 GG as a SS and went to 4 ASG. But despite hitting a respectable .294, his OPS was just .723, and that’s just not enough for a HOF vote.
Carlos Pulido – Gets a HOF nomination for his 527 HRs, but a 1B with a .913 OPS and only 1 ASG doesn’t get a sniff in this HOF.
Adam Williams – A C/DH who hit a nice .307/.413/.507 (.920 OPS), but only 261 HR and less than 1000 R/RBI. 3 ASG and a SS. Not enough.
Alex Lopez – I’m a fan of the everyday reliever in this game, but the overall numbers have to be higher. He pitched over 1300 innings, but 1.37 WHIP and 4.04 ERA aren’t HOF numbers, even in Capra.
Zachrey Cohen Does not belong on this list.